New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition similar games & best alternatives

New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition

PC (Microsoft Windows), Nintendo Switch, Mac • 2015

Should you play it?

A captivating detective adventure with elements of mysticism, telling a story of kidnapped children and mafia bosses.

What works
  • Engaging and varied puzzles
  • Compelling story and atmosphere
  • Large map with fast travel
  • Bonus chapter and achievements
  • Quality voice acting and graphics
Things to keep in mind
  • Some puzzles can be frustrating
  • Limited hidden object scenes
  • Minor translation and ui issues
  • Story can be predictable
  • Single save file limitation

What to play next

Similar games, hidden gems, and fresh directions from this game.

Top picks

Games that feel the closest overall

Hidden Gems

Less popular games with surprisingly high similarity

If you liked…

Recommendations by what you enjoyed most

  • Autonomy

    Heretic: Shadow of the Serpent Riders

  • Competence

    Death Squared

  • Escapism

    Driver® Parallel Lines

Similarity map

Explore nearby similar games and see why they’re close.

How to use the graph
Similarity map

Each dot is a game. They are arranged from the same motivation profile as in the “Why this game works” section below. Closer dots usually mean more similar reasons to play (exploration, competition, relaxation, etc.)—not that one game is “better” than another.

  • Purple star: this page’s game — everything on the map is relative to it.
  • Coloured chips: click to highlight games that mainly differ on that motivation; click again to reset.
  • Dotted line: link between this page’s game and the one selected for comparison.
  • Hover a dot for a screenshot preview, score, and top score gaps; click to compare in the panel on the right.
  • Scroll or double-click the chart to zoom out and see more games.

Why don’t the axes read like a score? This view uses t-SNE: it only keeps who is close to whom. The scales are not “good to bad” or hours played—they separate groups on the map. Read distance between dots, not the axis numbers (hidden on purpose).

New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition: A very typical example of its motivational profile. Motivations that often define this kind of title include Survival, Violence, Competition, Thrill. It leans lower than usual among comparable games on Intimacy, Expression, Fellowship.

Why this game works

A motivational profile of the game, with the closest similar game for each player motivation.

  • Autonomy

    Game with the same Autonomy vibe

    4

    "Players have freedom to explore complex levels, use inventory items strategically, and choose weapons and power-ups at will."

    Capsule for Heretic: Shadow of the Serpent Riders Heretic: Shadow of the Serpent Riders

    "Players have freedom to explore multiple locations, use inventory items in various orders, and choose difficulty levels and gameplay aids."

  • Competence

    Game with the same Competence vibe

    4

    "The game offers challenging puzzles that require skill, coordination, and problem-solving, with increasing difficulty and feedback through success or failure."

    Capsule for Death Squared Death Squared

    "The game offers a variety of puzzles with moderate to challenging difficulty, requiring problem solving and puzzle mastery."

  • Competition

    Game with the same Competition vibe

    -4

    "Focus is on individual puzzle solving and story progression without competitive or ranked elements."

    Capsule for The Entropy Centre The Entropy Centre

    "Focus is on individual puzzle solving and story progression without competitive or ranked elements."

  • Continuation

    Game with the same Continuation vibe

    3

    "Players report long play sessions, replay value, and habitual return to the game and series."

    Capsule for A Shelter Full of Cats A Shelter Full of Cats

    "Players report long play sessions, replay value with bonus chapter and achievements, and habitual return to the game."

  • Cooperation

    Game with the same Cooperation vibe

    -5

    "Entirely single-player experience with no multiplayer or cooperative gameplay."

    Capsule for The Last of Us™ Part I The Last of Us™ Part I

    "Entirely single-player experience with no multiplayer or cooperative gameplay."

  • Creativity

    Game with the same Creativity vibe

    3

    "Players manipulate and combine objects creatively to solve puzzles, though within the predefined game structure."

    Capsule for The Room 4: Old Sins The Room 4: Old Sins

    "Players engage in combining objects and solving puzzles creatively, though within predefined game structures."

  • Domination

    Game with the same Domination vibe

    -5

    "No evidence of exerting control or superiority over others; gameplay is solitary and non-competitive."

    Capsule for Ori and the Blind Forest Ori and the Blind Forest

    "No evidence of exerting control or superiority over others; gameplay is solitary and non-competitive."

  • Escapism

    Game with the same Escapism vibe

    4

    "Players use the game to relive nostalgic memories, immerse in a stylized 1970s and 2000s New York, and enjoy a story-driven escape."

    Capsule for Driver® Parallel Lines Driver® Parallel Lines

    "Players use the game to immerse in a mysterious 1950s New York setting, escaping real life through story and puzzles."

  • Expectation

    Game with the same Expectation vibe

    -4

    "Players engage voluntarily for enjoyment and personal interest rather than obligation or external pressure."

    Capsule for Hellsplit: Arena Hellsplit: Arena

    "Players engage voluntarily for enjoyment and personal interest rather than obligation or external pressure."

  • Experimenting

    Game with the same Experimenting vibe

    2

    "Some exploration and puzzle experimentation encouraged, though within a structured narrative and gameplay."

    Capsule for Return to Monkey Island Return to Monkey Island

    "Some exploration and puzzle experimentation is encouraged, but within a structured narrative and gameplay flow."

  • Exploration

    Game with the same Exploration vibe

    3

    "Game involves traveling through diverse locations and discovering collectibles and secrets."

    Capsule for Darkarta: A Broken Heart's Quest Collector's Edition Darkarta: A Broken Heart's Quest Collector's Edition

    "Game involves discovering new areas and secrets in a large map with fast travel and many locations."

  • Expression

    Game with the same Expression vibe

    -3

    "Limited customization; players experience a fixed protagonist and preset environments."

    Capsule for Conarium Conarium

    "Limited customization; players experience a fixed protagonist and predefined environments."

  • Fantasy

    Game with the same Fantasy vibe

    3

    "Includes supernatural and fantasy elements within a noir detective setting, blending imaginative fiction with mystery."

    Capsule for The Monster Inside The Monster Inside

    "Story includes paranormal and supernatural elements blended with noir detective fiction."

  • Fellowship

    Game with the same Fellowship vibe

    -5

    "No social or community features; gameplay is solitary."

    Capsule for Sekiro™: Shadows Die Twice - GOTY Edition Sekiro™: Shadows Die Twice - GOTY Edition

    "No social or community features; gameplay is solitary."

  • Growth

    Game with the same Growth vibe

    4

    "Players develop skills in puzzle solving and progress through increasingly difficult challenges."

    Capsule for Nihilumbra Nihilumbra

    "Players develop puzzle-solving skills and progress through increasingly complex challenges."

  • Health

    Game with the same Health vibe

    -5

    "Sedentary gameplay typical of point-and-click adventure games."

    Capsule for Syberia: The World Before Syberia: The World Before

    "Sedentary gameplay typical of point-and-click adventure games."

  • Idle

    Game with the same Idle vibe

    -4

    "Requires focused attention to solve puzzles and progress; not suited for casual background play."

    Capsule for Lost Lands: The Four Horsemen Collector's Edition Lost Lands: The Four Horsemen Collector's Edition

    "Requires focused attention to solve puzzles and progress; not suitable for casual background play."

  • Intimacy

    Game with the same Intimacy vibe

    -5

    "No social interaction or relationship-building features."

    Capsule for METAL GEAR & METAL GEAR 2: Solid Snake METAL GEAR & METAL GEAR 2: Solid Snake

    "No social interaction or relationship-building features."

  • Leadership

    Game with the same Leadership vibe

    -5

    "No leadership or group management roles; single-player experience."

    Capsule for Half-Life 2: Lost Coast Half-Life 2: Lost Coast

    "No leadership or group management roles; single-player experience."

  • Progression

    Game with the same Progression vibe

    4

    "Players accumulate items, clues, and achievements as they advance through the story and puzzles."

    Capsule for True Fear: Forsaken Souls Part 2 True Fear: Forsaken Souls Part 2

    "Players accumulate items, collectibles, and achievements as they advance through the story."

  • Relaxation

    Game with the same Relaxation vibe

    3

    "Generally relaxing gameplay with balanced challenge and atmospheric music."

    Capsule for The Secret Order 2: Masked Intent The Secret Order 2: Masked Intent

    "Generally relaxing gameplay with balanced challenge and atmospheric music."

  • Sensation

    Game with the same Sensation vibe

    2

    "Visuals and sound create a pleasant atmosphere but sensory stimulation is moderate and not intense."

    Capsule for Port Royale 3 Port Royale 3

    "Visuals and sound create an engaging atmosphere but sensory stimulation is moderate and subtle."

  • Status

    Game with the same Status vibe

    -5

    "No social recognition or status systems present."

    Capsule for Resident Evil 7 Biohazard Resident Evil 7 Biohazard

    "No social recognition or status systems present."

  • Story

    Game with the same Story vibe

    4

    "Strong narrative immersion with cutscenes, character interactions, and unfolding mystery."

    Capsule for Enigmatis 2: The Mists of Ravenwood Enigmatis 2: The Mists of Ravenwood

    "Strong narrative immersion with cutscenes, voice acting, and a compelling mystery plot."

  • Strategy

    Game with the same Strategy vibe

    3

    "Requires logical thinking and planning to solve puzzles and use items effectively."

    Capsule for Lake Haven - Chrysalis Lake Haven - Chrysalis

    "Requires logical thinking and planning to solve puzzles and use items effectively."

  • Thrill

    Game with the same Thrill vibe

    1

    "Mild suspense from mystery elements, but overall calm and controlled experience."

    Capsule for Whisper of the House Whisper of the House

    "Some suspense from mystery elements, but overall a calm and steady experience."

  • Value

    Game with the same Value vibe

    4

    "Players report good value for money due to length, content, and replayability."

    Capsule for Lost Lands: The Four Horsemen Collector's Edition Lost Lands: The Four Horsemen Collector's Edition

    "Players report good value for money with long playtime and replayability."

  • Violence

    Game with the same Violence vibe

    -4

    "No combat or destruction; gameplay focuses on puzzle solving and exploration."

    Capsule for The Swapper The Swapper

    "No combat or destruction; gameplay focuses on puzzle solving and exploration."

  • Survival

    Game with the same Survival vibe

    -5

    "No survival or threat avoidance mechanics; stable and safe gameplay environment."

    Capsule for Hatsune Miku: Project DIVA Mega Mix+ Hatsune Miku: Project DIVA Mega Mix+

    "No survival or threat avoidance mechanics; stable and safe gameplay environment."

Last update: 01/06/2026